There’s no better way to bring people together on vacation than with incredible food, and the Lake Harmony area is serving up flavors that are as memorable as the mountain views. Whether you’re planning a corporate retreat or a big group getaway with friends or family, the local dining scene in and around Lake Harmony, Blakeslee, and Jim Thorpe offers something for every palate. From lakeside lunches to craft brews and hearty brunches, this 2025 Foodie Guide has all the must-visit spots to satisfy your cravings while staying at your Pocono Mountain Rentals property.
Lake Harmony Classics
Nick’s Lake House
📍 Lake Harmony
A local institution and a favorite of our Co-Owner Greg Petrillo, Nick’s Lake House is the perfect place for group dining with scenic lakeside views. The casual, welcoming vibe, wide menu selection, and friendly staff make it a go-to for both lunch and dinner. Enjoy your meal outside on the deck overlooking the water or inside by the fireplace during cooler months. Menu Must-Try: Marinated Grilled Salmon
Terra Cottage Café & Gift Shop
📍 Lake Harmony
For a cozy breakfast or lunch that feels like a hug, Terra Cottage is a must. Staff member Amanda swears by this charming spot. Try their thick cinnamon swirl french toast stuffed with strawberry cream cheese and sliced bananas. Their charming setting makes it ideal for laid-back mornings with the crew. Don’t skip the gift shop as it’s perfect for grabbing a little local flair to bring home. Don’t Miss This: Lobster Salad Croissant
Piggy’s Restaurant
📍 Lake Harmony
Known for its playful pig-themed decor and hearty breakfast fare, Piggy’s is one of the most talked-about spots according to our Reservationist Carmen McGilberry. Guests rave about the friendly atmosphere and satisfying plates, from French toast to hearty omelets. It’s a great casual option for families or groups looking to fuel up before a day of exploring. Menu Highlight: Homemade Belgium Waffle
Pizza, Pub Food & Casual Bites
Dominic’s Pizza
📍 Pocono Lake
If your group needs a quick, reliable, and crowd-pleasing meal, Dominic’s Pizza in Blakeslee is your best bet. Their pizza is cheesy, satisfying, available for takeout, and perfect for a chill night at your vacation rental. Plus, they also offer stromboli and salads if you want to switch it up.
Chat-n-Chew Cafe
📍 Blakeslee
This local gem is one of our team’s top comfort food picks. With a homey diner feel and delicious options like burgers, homemade soups, and all-day breakfast, Chat-n-Chew is as friendly as it is tasty. Bonus: it’s super group-friendly and usually quick to seat larger parties.
Jubilee Restaurant
📍 Pocono Pines
Serving up a little bit of everything, Jubilee is a beloved breakfast and dinner spot with something for everyone. Think pancakes, pastas, sandwiches, and seafood. Another staff favorite, it’s ideal for groups with diverse tastes or families with kids. Don’t forget, Thursday and Sunday are Wing Nights!
Breweries & Bars with Atmosphere
Boulder View Tavern
📍 Lake Harmony
If you’re looking for scenic drinks and a relaxed vibe, Boulder View Tavern checks all the boxes. Great for a casual night out, they offer live music, American-style pub fare, and plenty of beer options. Grab a table outside for views of Big Boulder Lake. Stop by on a Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday between 5-7pm for Happy Hour Specials!
Molly Maguire’s Irish Pub
📍 Jim Thorpe
For a lively pub atmosphere and hearty Irish-American fare, head to Molly Maguire’s. Located in the heart of historic Jim Thorpe, it’s perfect for post-exploration drinks and dinner. Fish and chips, burgers, and Guinness are just the beginning.
Broadway Grille & Pub
📍 Jim Thorpe
Located at the Inn at Jim Thorpe, Broadway Grille is the kind of place you’ll want to return to again and again. It’s a staff favorite for brunch, dinner, and drinks, especially thanks to its warm ambiance and creative cocktails. Don’t miss their weekend brunch menu, ideal for a slow start to your day.
Myst
📍 Jim Thorpe
If you’re in the mood for something a bit trendier, check out Myst Japanese Restaurant. With a sleek atmosphere, tasty sushi options, and elevated cocktails, it’s great for a date night or girls’ night out. Their small plate menu encourages sharing, which makes it perfect for groups.
Pro Tip: Stay In and Dine Together
Want a night in? Many of these restaurants offer takeout or delivery, making it easy to enjoy delicious local food from the comfort of your Pocono Mountain Rentals home. Order a few pizzas, pick up your favorite craft beers, and enjoy a relaxed dinner around the dining table or outside by the firepit.
Final Bites
From hearty brunches to lakeside dinners and cozy cafés, Lake Harmony and its surrounding towns are filled with memorable dining spots for every kind of traveler. Use this 2025 guide as your go-to resource for discovering the best eats around. And don’t forget to ask our team for their latest favorites. They’re always happy to help you eat like a local!
